“In rhinoplasty my aim is never an 'operated' nose; I plan a natural, balanced result according to each patient's facial proportions and breathing function.”
Legal information and certificates
Republic of Türkiye Ministry of Health · Istanbul Provincial Health Directorate — Practice Compliance Certificate — Certificate no. 284426293 · 08.08.2025 · View certificate (PDF)
Ministry of Health · General Directorate of Health Services — International Health Tourism Authorization Certificate — Certificate no. 2026034015610080000480109 · 08.05.2026 · View certificate (PDF)
Responsible physician: Op. Dr. Selman Taşkın · Specialist in Plastic, Reconstructive and Aesthetic Surgery · Specialist registration no. 150440 · Diploma no. 13660
There are two main techniques in rhinoplasty: open and closed methods. Both are accepted by modern surgery and widely applied. "Which is better?" question has no absolute answer — preferred by case complexity, surgeon experience and patient expectations. This guide compares both techniques in detail by technical difference, scar, view area, recovery, result quality and cost.
Technical Difference: Incision Location and Surgical View
Open rhinoplasty: small "V" or "step" external incision on columella (vertical soft strip between nostrils) + standard internal incisions. Skin lifted up exposing nasal skeleton with full view. Surgeon's both hands free, suture areas precisely visible. Closed rhinoplasty: all incisions inside nose (intercartilaginous, intracartilaginous or marginal). External skin remains intact. Surgeon doesn't see directly, works under tissue — requires more "manual experience".
Skin Scar: Visible?
Open rhinoplasty: incision on top of columella prominent first 1-3 months (pink line), fades 3-6 months, becomes almost invisible at 12 months. Microscopic scar remains but unnoticeable in daily view (not visible from 1 meter distance). Closed rhinoplasty: no external scar. Small scars inside nostrils that are invisible anyway. If patient very scar-sensitive can prefer closed; however with experienced surgeon open scar practically not a problem.
View Area and Surgical Detail
Open: 360 degrees, full view. Surgeon directly examines all nose structures (cartilage, bone, septum, alar). Ideal for precise suturing, cartilage graft placement, asymmetry correction. Complex cases (revision, thick skin, small face) done more controlled with open. Closed: limited view, tactile sense more important. Ideal for simple-moderate cases (hump removal, mild alar reduction, mild tip correction). With experienced surgeon closed result also excellent.
Recovery Process and Edema Difference
Open rhinoplasty: lymphatic drainage temporarily disrupted as skin lifted. More edema and bruising first 1-2 weeks. Columella incision sensitivity 2-3 weeks. Full recovery 12-18 months (slow tip softening). Closed rhinoplasty: skin-tissue relationship less disturbed, less edema and bruising. No columella problem. Full recovery 9-12 months. Return to social life 5-7 days earlier in closed. Splint removal at 1 week for both.
Operation Duration and Cost
Open rhinoplasty: 2.5-4 hours (longer, view and correction takes time). Cost 10-20% higher than closed. Surgeon fee higher as accepts more complex cases. Closed rhinoplasty: 1.5-3 hours. Lower cost. Price ranges similar in Turkey but varies by clinic. At TSHEALTH CLINIC both techniques applied at same high standard; technique selected per case, cost-independent.
Which Technique When? Decision Matrix
OPEN RHINOPLASTY PREFERRED: 1) Revision cases (previous anatomy complex). 2) Cases requiring cartilage graft. 3) Very asymmetric nose. 4) Thick skin (tip definition difficult). 5) Young surgeon's learning phase. CLOSED RHINOPLASTY PREFERRED: 1) Hump removal only. 2) Mild alar reduction. 3) Thin skin, simple case. 4) Very scar-sensitive patient. 5) Quick recovery desired. Most modern surgeons apply both techniques, case evaluated. Op. Dr. Selman Taşkın at TSHEALTH CLINIC experienced in both techniques and recommends most suitable for your case.
SSS
Which better?
No absolute; case-specific. Open for complex, closed for simple.
Visible scar in open?
Prominent first 1-3 months, fades in 12 months.
Less bruising in closed?
Yes, less edema and bruising in closed.
Which more natural?
Natural result possible in both; surgeon experience important.
Cost difference?
Open 10-20% higher; varies by case.
Which surgeon to choose?
Certified plastic surgeon experienced in both techniques.
Who performs Open vs Closed Rhinoplasty?
Open vs Closed Rhinoplasty and all aesthetic and surgical procedures are planned and personally performed by Op. Dr. Selman Taşkın, Specialist in Plastic, Reconstructive and Aesthetic Surgery. A graduate of İstanbul University-Cerrahpaşa Faculty of Medicine with reconstructive microsurgery experience at Chang Gung Memorial Hospital (Taiwan), Dr. Taşkın's expertise is the foundation of safe, natural results.
In the closed technique all incisions are made inside the nostrils, leaving no visible external scar. Swelling is usually less and recovery is somewhat faster.
What Is Open Rhinoplasty?
In the open technique a small incision is added across the columella (the bridge separating the nostrils). This gives the surgeon wider visibility and precise control over the nasal structure.
Comparison by Scarring
The closed technique leaves no external scar. The columella scar in the open technique fades within a few months and usually becomes unnoticeable.
Swelling and Recovery
Swelling usually resolves faster with the closed technique. Tip swelling in the open technique may last a little longer, but the difference is limited to a few weeks in most patients.
Which Technique When?
For simple hump removal or minor revisions the closed technique may be preferred. For complex tip work, revision surgery and cases requiring grafts, the open technique offers an advantage.
How Is the Decision Made?
Technique choice is not standardized; the surgeon evaluates your nasal anatomy, skin thickness and goals to recommend the most suitable method.
What is the Open Technique?
In open rhinoplasty, a small (4-5 mm) incision is made on the columella (bridge between nostrils), skin is lifted, and the nasal structure becomes directly visible. The surgeon works on the tissue with full vision.
Advantages: maximum visibility, precise suturing, easy asymmetry correction, easy cartilage graft application, preferred in revisions.
What is the Closed Technique?
In closed technique, all incisions are inside the nostrils, no external incision. The surgeon works "endonasally" without fully lifting the skin.
Advantages: no external scar, less swelling (minimum skin dissection), faster recovery, no columella nerve sensitivity risk.
When is Closed Preferred?
First rhinoplasty, mild-moderate deformities, dorsal hump reduction, tip refinement, patients wanting fast recovery. Ideal for young patients, thin skin, no asymmetry cases.
Scar Comparison
Open: 4-5 mm horizontal scar on columella. Fades at 3 months, almost invisible at 6 months. With proper suturing technique, undetectable without loupes. Closed: all incisions internal, zero external scar.
Recovery Time Difference
In closed technique, edema is approximately 20% less and resolves faster. In open technique, lymphatic drainage delays 2-3 weeks due to full skin elevation. Final result is 12 months in both; at month 6, open looks slightly more swollen.
Complication Risks
Both techniques are safe but have differences: Open — minor scar (rarely), columella nerve sensitivity up to 3 months. Closed — limited visibility increases asymmetry risk with inexperienced surgeons. Result consistency depends on surgeon experience in both.
Which is Right for You?
Decision is not technique preference alone but anatomy and goals. In initial consultation, Experienced Team evaluates your nasal structure, skin thickness, functional issues and aesthetic expectations and recommends the suitable technique. Hybrid approach also used in some cases.
Does open rhinoplasty leave a scar?
Yes, 4-5 mm horizontal scar on columella. However, within 6 months it adapts to surrounding skin and is undetectable from normal distance.
Which technique gives more natural results?
Both give equally natural results. Naturalness depends on surgeon experience and patient anatomy, not technique.
Should my first rhinoplasty be open or closed?
Closed preferred for mild-moderate deformities. If significant asymmetry or functional issue, open gives safer results.
Why is open preferred for revisions?
In second surgery, anatomy is altered due to scar tissue. Open visibility is critical for proper graft placement and correction.
How much visibility in closed?
Sufficient for experienced surgeons. Endoscopic illumination and fine instruments used to view anatomic landmarks.
Is swelling longer in open?
In early period yes, 15-20% more edema. But at 12 months, same result with both techniques.
Which technique to reduce nose size?
General reduction (bone + cartilage) possible in both. If detailed tip shaping needed, open technique has advantage.
Which technique for cartilage grafts?
For costal (rib) or septal cartilage grafts, open technique preferred as grafts require precise placement.
Who performs Rhinoplasty?
Rhinoplasty and all aesthetic and surgical procedures are planned and personally performed by Op. Dr. Selman Taşkın, Specialist in Plastic, Reconstructive and Aesthetic Surgery. A graduate of İstanbul University-Cerrahpaşa Faculty of Medicine with reconstructive microsurgery experience at Chang Gung Memorial Hospital (Taiwan), Dr. Taşkın's expertise is the foundation of safe, natural results.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the open rhinoplasty scar permanent?
No. The thin columella scar fades within a few months and is usually unnoticeable unless examined closely.
Is the closed technique always better?
No. It has the advantage of no scar, but the open technique gives more predictable results in complex cases.
Which heals faster?
Swelling usually resolves a little faster with the closed technique, but the difference is not significant for most patients.
Which is suitable for revision?
The open technique is usually preferred for revision rhinoplasty because it gives the surgeon better visibility.
Which for tip work?
The open technique offers more precise control for detailed tip shaping.
Do I choose the technique?
Your preference matters, but the final recommendation belongs to the surgeon assessing your nasal anatomy.
Tedavi Süreci
TSHEALTH CLINIC'te tüm uygulamalar 4 aşamada gerçekleştirilir: Ön Görüşme (ücretsiz, 15-30 dk) → Tedavi Planı → Uygulama (steril ortam, FDA onaylı cihazlar) → Kontrol Randevusu. 7/24 WhatsApp desteği.